We are not just saying no cause he’s black, we are saying no because Cap was chosen, given the super-solider serum, and he is just irreplaceable. Falcon has done nothing even remotely close to living up to the title Captain America, Bucky has done more, but No one can fill those shoes, No One.

NO!!! Only because Bucky should have got the sheiks not that stupid guy that plays a bird in the mcu! Bucky knew cap before he did!

Chris Evans qill always be the greatest Captain America. Dont get me wrong Anthony Mackie is good but i just dont think he can handle the shield and being Falcon

they can never replace a character like steve. i personally don’t like chris evans as a person, but he’s the only one meant to play the role of steve rogers. that’s just something they can’t replace. this isn’t spider-man.

chris is the only cap and it will be hard to “replace” him

Steve Rogers is basically irreplaceable as Captain America due to his pure heart. We still haven't seen enough of Falcon to judge or compare him to Steve but based on what we know, he is not "ready". Now if I had to choose between Falcon and Bucky, then Falcon takes it all the way.

I said no but I'm disappointed in the comments here. Bucky is the least deserving of the shield compared to Sam (Falcon). Bucky is not only mentally unstable but even he admits that he is still trying to find himself. He is not ready for the Captain America role.

It's not that Anthology Mackie isn't good, it's just that NO ONE can replace Steve Rogers, Captain America was him. he was chosen not The Falcon. and Bucky should have gotten the shield, he deserved it the most. he has known Steve since they were kids and would have never given the shield away.