Both are very in tune with their respective character but Arkham City not only does it have a better narrative, it originated most of the gameplay aspects in the superhero game genre that spiderman used.

Arkham City had better villains a better story and it’s Batman I mean cmon man Spider-Man ps4 wouldn’t even exist without the Arkham games.

Both are good, but the Arkham series was more revolutionary for Batman games than the PS4 game was for Spider-Man. In my opinion, the PS4 game is more like previous open-world Spider-Man games than people like to admit and while it's mechanics are fine-tuned, I just don't think it's such a step up.

Without the mechanics and engine design that built the Arkham games Spider-Man game would not exist. The Arkham series created the mechanics that are used for spiderman

I personally enjoyed the story and boss fights of Arkham city not to down spider man ps4 but the boss fights were also good and the web swinging was perfect but Batman Arkham city is the game that I would go back and try to get a platinum trophy

Just has a better story and more replay ability as it has challenge maps and multiple characters

Better story, gameplay through the game is amazing, gadgets are quick fired instead of a wheel.

batman

Better story better bosses better fighting

Better story, the dark vibes from the game and fight are intense

Just because I feel more attached to Arkham city than ps4 Spider-Man

Arkham city has a lot more memorable story in my opinion

Arkham City because you face all of batmans villains in the game and the combat is incredible. Also u dont have anything like the mj missions in arkham city.